The uncertainty in Seth's voice felt like being stabbed with his own failure. It was working, telling Seth about his past life, but did he want it to? Would it be kinder to just let Seth think he was a manipulative and/or crazy asshole and get back to his regular life, or was it cruel to keep these memories from him? Caleb didn't know. None of them knew. "Jeanne-Marie Beaubier. Aurora. Jean-Paul's twin sister."