Caleb couldn't actually bring himself to say something as ridiculous as 'You were an X-Man, once'. Instead, he let himself ramble, which probably wasn't much better. "You're not supposed to remember anything. Scott would disagree, he'd probably have marched right up to you and ordered you to remember like you were still on a team together. I was trying to leave it alone. If you didn't recognize me as Alex right away, no big deal. I'm Caleb now; you're Seth now. Who knows if Jean-Paul ever gave two fucks about Alex in particular anyway. Not like he did about Jeanne-Marie. Or Kyle. Or his students."